The citizens of Arizona have been looking forward to their coin with great anticipation for years now. The Arizona Quarter Commission was first formed back in 2005 to begin receiving public input regarding the designs and key elements that should appear on the Arizona Quarter. The 24-member commission met in public 12 times between November 2005 and July 2006 to consider input from the public, and extensive outreach efforts were made to civic and citizen's groups such as Native American tribal groups, Boy Scouts, numerous clubs and schools, and through the media to the general public. The goal was to reach as much of a general consensus as possible about the designs and message that would appear on the Arizona State Quarter.
A Special Arizona State Quarter AmbassadorAlthough the State of Arizona didn't officially appoint an ambassador to spread the message about plans to develop the Arizona Quarter, such a person emerged in the form of commission member Matthew Rounis. Matthew was in the fourth grade at the time he was appointed the commission, and he traveled all over the state giving presentations to his student peers about how important it was to become involved in the Arizona Quarter design process.
The Arizona Quarter Design NarrativesAs part of the State Quarter design process, Arizona submitted five design narratives to the U.S. Mint. These narratives are meant to be very brief, and are the basis from which the Mint's artists actually create the coin designs. Like virtually all of the other State Quarters, the Arizona Quarter design was created by a U.S. Mint artist, rather than a resident of the State of Arizona. This artist selection process has been controversial, and the Mint has taken steps in the past few years to enlarge the ranks from which coin artists are selected through its Artistic Infusion Program.
The narrative for the winning coin design, which is titled "Grand Canyon State" reads as follows:
The Grand Canyon in the upper background with the rising sun. In the foreground, the magnificent Saguaro Cactus with several large branches (arms) curving upward. A banner with the inscription "Grand Canyon State" separates the two elements to indicate two distinctive Arizona scenes.
The State of Arizona held a public poll to gather input from the state's residents regarding the five final design candidates. The voting took place online, and the percentage of votes received by each design was as follows:
- 1st Place (50%) - Grand Canyon & Saguaro
- 2nd Place (26%) - Saguaro Cactus Scene (no Canyon)
- 3rd Place (13%) - Grand Canyon (only)
- 4th Place (11%) - Navajo Code Talkers
- 5th Place (<1%) - Powell's Grand Canyon Survey
Judging by these voting results, it is clear that Arizona residents feel that the majestic Saguaro Cactus is more emblematic of their state's uniqueness than the Grand Canyon is. Or maybe they just couldn't wrap their minds around depicting the vast and mighty Grand Canyon in less than 1 square, err round inch of space!
The Arizona Quarter's BannerOne of the more interesting design elements on the Arizona Quarter is the banner separating the Saguaro Cactus and desert scene from the Grand Canyon behind it. This banner is an extremely important design element because it is supposed to be telling the viewer that Saguaro Cacti do not grow in the Grand Canyon. I don't think this design element was successful in its goal, though, because of the way the design melds together on the right side.
Overall, though, I think the Arizona Quarter is among the better designs in the 50 State Quarterstm series. Although it's a busy design, it is well-executed and pleasing to look at.